Wednesday, December 29, 2004


(1) Opera is a sensual art. This first of all. Anyone who heard her knew it -- the glory of the unamplified human voice. But also it's in sets, costumes, the orchestra, and the symmetry of a well-turned phrase or, er, (dance) turn. (Or --)

(2) Opera is a dramatic art. Never mind Kerman; I mean the energy released and channeled, between all participants, by placing performers among each other and before an audience. (Aristotle was an early commenter on this phenomenon.) Some performers are attuned to these currents and can conjure marvels; others less so. Ditto directors, and librettists, and of course composers.

(3) Opera illuminates the world, and one's experience in it. Ours, or one comparable -- in the smaller touches and broader. On this hook come the ridiculous contortions of "Regietheater", but fortunately that hasn't taken much hold here. We learn from how a performance shows the world, or wallow in it, or find it poorly-done, or just intolerable. (A friend finds the character Otello too blockheaded to be convincing, or sympathetic. I find Khovanschina shockingly close to an apology for Wahabbi theocracy.)

(4) Opera illuminates its own world: the history, present, and future of opera. Every performance revises all of these, to our delight or chagrin. A new work may be revealed, another incrementally forgotten. For those who keep track, an unexpectedly impressive debut may redeem a dull evening, or a favorite's missteps ruin otherwise great enjoyment. For friends or colleages especially. And even those far from "inside" are part of the history too, having been at that earlier performance when it was, you know, a Golden Age of this or that...

(5) Operagoing is a social activity, beyond and around the sitting-in-the-dark-as-an-audience part. This, oddly enough, may be the only definite idea most people have about opera. Still significant, though.

*     *     *

Now it seems to me that not only do we experience an opera performance through each of these lenses, but all of us have personal (that is, differing) tastes and priority-weightings as to every one. So one of us might find the most significant sense-element of a production to be singing, while another responds most strongly to handsome sets, and another to the sound of the orchestra. At the same time one might be most interested in the sensual aspects, while another seeks out the strongest dramatic experiences (by his lights, naturally) and barely registers direct sense impressions, and so on.

One problem is that a strong impression as to one of the aspects -- especially one of particular interest to the operagoer -- can make it hard to admit or even see the truth as to another. I've pointed to one example of this.

Another problem is that that current writing doesn't cover all of these aspects terribly well. But more in another post.

1 comment:

  1. Obviously replica watches uk the brand founded by Edouard Heuer in 1860 knows very well that his are (genuine) imitations of the most famous GMT Master II whose part of the blue replica watches uk bezel indicates the 12 daytime hours and the remaining nighttime hours in black, but for a third of the price it offers a excellent quality product replica watches uk and that you can buy.
    However the latest TAG Heuer Aquaracer GMT is, a model that improved over the years offers outstanding fake rolex performance. The 43 mm diameter steel case is quite impressive but offers a good 300 meters of waterproofness. It is animated by the fake rolex reliable Caliber 7 automatic movement with second time zone (ETA 2895-2 base).
    Aesthetically, this fake rolex GMT features the classic dial of the Aquaracer line decorated with horizontal lines that mimic an air intake from an offshore and the excellent fake Rolex stainless steel TAG Heuer bracelet.
    Unfortunately Tudor, the replica rolex affordable Rolex brand, still does not offer a Black Bay GMT in blue and black color and the appearance of the TAG Heuer replica rolex Aquaracer GMT is gorgeous. With a price of € 2,900 it allows you to save over replica rolex six thousand from the Rolex Batman which to materialize it become many replica Rolex more.


Absolutely no axe-grinding, please.